Why Jealousy Hits So Hard (And What It’s Really Trying to Protect) EP. 154
Jealousy can feel overwhelming, shame-filled, and honestly… kind of brutal.
A delayed text, a shift in energy, hearing your partner mention someone else, and suddenly your body is spiraling before your brain can catch up.
If you’ve ever felt jealous and then judged yourself for it, this episode is for you.
In this episode of Nope! We’re Not Monogamous, I’m breaking down why jealousy feels so intense, especially in non-monogamy, and what’s often really happening underneath it.
We talk about:
→ why jealousy is a normal human emotion
→ the fear, comparison, and old wounds underneath it
→ why shame makes jealousy feel even bigger
→ how to start understanding what jealousy is trying to tell you
If jealousy has been running the show, this is exactly why I created Beyond Jealousy, to help you feel more secure in yourself and your relationships.
💜 Learn more about Beyond Jealousy: www.elleciapaine.com/jealousy
📰 Subscribe to Not A Monogamous Newsletter to stay up to date with new episodes and offerings from Ellecia. https://elleciapaine.podia.com/newsletter
❤️ Enjoying the show? The best way to thank us is by following and leaving a review or a note. And if you want more, join our Patreon! http://www.patreon.com/notmonogamous
👀 Find Us Online🌍 Website: https://www.elleciapaine.com
📘 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/elleciapaine
📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/elleciapaine/
Music: Composer/Author (CA): Oscar Lindstein
STIM IPI: 572 393 237
TRANSCRIPT:
[00:00:00] Speaker: Have you ever had one small moment send you into a full on spiral, like a text that took too long a change in tone, your partner mentioning someone else's name?
Seeing them light up in a way that suddenly made your stomach drop and suddenly you're not just reacting to what's happening. You're comparing, you're overthinking, you're feeling like ashamed that this still gets to you. You're wondering why something that's like so small can feel so huge. If that sounds familiar, then this episode is for you because jealousy is one of the most misunderstood emotions that we have.
And for a lot of people, it's not just jealousy, it's [00:01:00] fear, it's grief, it's old wounds. It's the ache of wondering if you're even enough. So today, that's where we're going. Hey friends. Welcome back to Nope, we're not monogamous. I'm Ellecia Paine. You're a non-monogamous relationship coach and I help people build more secure, honest, and deeply connected relationships without abandoning themselves in the process.
So today we're gonna talk about jealousy again, right? And not the watered down version. Not the version where someone tells you to just be more evolved, not the version where you're told to communicate better and somehow magically stop feeling activated. Let's talk about the kind of jealousy that like lives in your body, the kind that
makes your chest tighten up the kind that has you spiraling over things that you wish didn't affect you. The kind that can make you feel ashamed for even having the feeling in the first place, right? [00:02:00] Because jealousy is not proof that you're doing something wrong or you're failing, and it doesn't mean that you're bad at love or polyamory or non-monogamy.
Most of the time. Jealousy is a signal. Your body is trying to protect something. Tender. And when you understand what it's actually trying to tell you, that's when things can start to shift. Right? So let's talk about it.
Okay, let's start here. Jealousy is human. It's not a flaw. It's not a character defect. It's not something broken inside of you. It's not something to fix it. Jealousy is a lot of times it's your mind and your body responding to like the possibility of loss. Loss of connection, loss of certainty, loss of attention, loss of safety.
Your nervous system doesn't always know what the difference is between. This feels unfamiliar and this is super dangerous, [00:03:00] right? So when something feels uncertain, especially in love, your body can react like there's an actual threat. Your heart starts racing, your chest tightens your thoughts, speed up.
You start scanning for danger. Because relationships matter so deeply to us, jealousy can feel really, really incredibly personal. But that doesn't mean it's telling you the truth. That doesn't mean it's serving up facts for you, right? A lot of the time, jealousy is less about what's actually happening right now in this moment, and more about what your body or your nervous system is afraid might happen.
That's an important distinction because if you treat every jealous feeling, like proof that something is wrong, you'll stay stuck in the spiral, right? But if you start seeing jealousy as, as information, as data instead of evidence, you can start shifting things there.
Okay. I really want you to know, like actually know that [00:04:00] jealousy is almost never just jealousy. Usually it's sitting on top of something deeper, many things deeper, right? Fear, grief, shame, old wounds, the ache of not feeling chosen, the fear of being forgotten, the fear of being abandoned. The fear that someone else will be more or better than you, right?
And that comparison piece, that one takes a lot of people out because jealousy has a really sneaky way of making us turn someone else into a mirror. So instead of just like noticing discomfort, your, your mind, your brain starts to build a whole story around this. Maybe they're hotter than me. Maybe they're easier, maybe they're more fun.
Maybe my partner likes them more. Maybe I'm not enough. Maybe they're better in bed. None of that is neutral. That story usually lands right on top of some of some old wound. Maybe you grew up. Feeling like love was inconsistent or like you had to perform to be chosen, or maybe you learned really [00:05:00] early on that being lovable meant you had to be easy, agreeable, desirable, perfect.
And so now in your adult relationships, jealousy doesn't, it's not just uncomfortable, right? It feels like a confirmation of this belief that you grew up with, like proof that your worst fear might actually be true. And that is why jealousy can feel so intense. Because it's not just about this particular moment in front of you or the particular actions that are happening.
Sometimes it's the young version of you being activated. Sometimes it's a a past version of you saying, please do not let this happen to me again. And that doesn't mean like you're immature, uh, or haven't grown. It just means something in you is tender and asking for care. Okay? And honestly, like one of the hardest parts of jealousy isn't even the jealousy itself.
Everything around the jealousy. It's what we've been taught to make jealousy mean because like culturally, we're handed two [00:06:00] really limited stories about jealousy. Story number one, if you're jealous, you're irrational, you're dramatic, you're needy, you're overreacting, basically, you are the problem. And story number two.
If you feel jealous, it must mean that someone is doing something wrong. Someone's betraying you, or they're crossing a line or they're causing harm. So the jealousy becomes proof that something bad is happening. And in monogamy, a lot of people structure their relationships around avoiding jealousy altogether, right?
Like the unspoken deal is like if we make enough rules. If we choose exclusivity, if we remove enough uncertainty, then maybe we never have to feel this discomfort at all. Right? But that's not actually how emotions work. Jealousy doesn't just like disappear because you've created a structure that's supposed to protect you.
It can still show up around like attention, emotional intimacy, porn, [00:07:00] fantasies, friendships, exes, or like just the fear of like drifting apart. But then you shift over to non-monogamy, and this like cultural conditioning hits even harder because now you've consciously agreed to something that includes openness.
Maybe your partner's dating someone else, maybe they're having sex with someone else. Maybe they're falling in love. And because you said yes to this, you agreed to this structure, your brain suddenly does this really brutal thing. Your brain is like, if nobody's technically doing anything wrong, if nobody's betraying me, they're not cheating, we agreed to this, then why do I feel so bad?
And that can quickly turn into, Hmm, there must be something wrong with me then. And that. Is where so many of us get stuck, because now you're not just dealing with jealousy, you're dealing with shame, like, shame for feeling activated, [00:08:00] shame for wanting reassurance, shame for having needs. Shame for not being like quote unquote good at this.
But jealousy's not a moral failure. You're not bad or wrong for having it. Feeling hurt doesn't make you weak. Feeling scared doesn't make you broken. Feeling activated doesn't mean you're not cut out for non-monogamy. It means something inside you is crying out and, and, and something in your body wants care.
It means a part of you may need more safety than you've been taught to ask for, and that's really, really important because jealousy itself usually isn't what Rex relationships, right? It's what happens when shame gets layered on, on top of it. Shame is what makes people hide, makes people explode, uh, do insane things.
It's what makes people shut down or pretend they're fine when they're not. But shame actually starts to lose its grip. When you stop making your [00:09:00] feelings mean something terrible about you, right? Like, like if you take away the shame.
No fix that
shame loses its grip. The moment you stop making your feelings. This feeling of jealousy or this feeling of shame means something bad about you, something terrible about you. You can feel jealousy and still be really deeply self-aware and you can feel jealousy and still be emotionally mature. You can feel jealousy and still be doing this great, doing a good job doing this beautifully relating well, right?
So the goal isn't to never feel jealousy. I mean, as much as I know we don't want to, but, but really the goal is to stop making your feelings into evidence that you're failing, that you're doing it wrong. [00:10:00] Okay? So the next time jealousy shows up, I want you to try something before you react, before you send the text, before you shut down, before you pick a fight.
Pause and ask yourself, what am I actually afraid? This means not what is my partner doing wrong? Not how do I stop feeling this, but like, what is this actually bringing up in me? Am I afraid of being replaced? Am I afraid I'm not enough? Am I afraid I'll be abandoned? Am I afraid I'll lose myself? Because when you can name the fears underneath the jealousy, you stop fighting the the surface emotion.
Start tending to the actual wound below that, right? That's, that's where you can start doing some healing and growth. It's not by becoming less emotional, but like becoming more, you wanna become more honest with yourself.
So if any of this hits home for you and you [00:11:00] realize jealousy has been carrying way more weight than you thought, I want you to know that this stuff is workable. Okay? You're not doomed to keep spiraling. You're not stuck feeling this way forever. I have been, been growing and changing and learning through jealousy for over a decade, 14 years or something.
You don't have to white knuckle. You don't have to hold on so tight. You don't have to white knuckle your way through love. Okay? This is exactly why I created Beyond Jealousy. It's an eight week group. Cor words are hard. This is exactly why I created Beyond Jealousy. It's an eight week group coaching program for you because understanding jealousy is important, okay?
You can listen to this podcast, you can listen to other podcasts. You can read all the books, but the insight alone doesn't usually stop the spiral. You have to actually do the work. Real change happens when you learn how to work with your body, with your triggers and your stories and your sense of worth in a way that actually feels safe, right?[00:12:00]
So, uh. Inside that program, we go deeper into what jealousy is really protecting. How to calm your nervous system when, when you're, when you're activated, how to calm your nervous system down, how to stop comparing yourself to other people. How to communicate without collapsing or exploding. How to feel more secure in yourself no matter what your partner's doing.
So if you're tired of jealousy running the show, the link for Beyond Monogamy, Nope. Not Beyond Monogamy, beyond Jealousy, is in the show notes. Uh, or you can go to www.elleciapaine.com/jealousy. And really as always, take what resonates. Leave the rest. Your relationships are unique to you. Your nervous system is unique to you.
Your path gets to look like yours. And if this episode helped you feel a little more seen, I'd really love it if you subscribed. Or left a review or a comment or shared it with someone who might need to hear this. Those things really do help more people find the show. They let me know that you're out there listening [00:13:00] and they help me keep having conversations like this.
Thanks for being here. Thanks for letting me into your ears and your heart for a little bit. Bye.