Choosing to Be Unnested: Polyamory Without a Live-In Partner, EP. 169

What if you're polyamorous, deeply in love, and have absolutely no desire to live with a romantic partner?

We talk a LOT about polyamory from the perspective of couples opening their relationships. But what about those of us who are intentionally choosing NOT to have a nesting partner?

In this episode of Nope! We're Not Monogamous, I'm talking about choosing to be unnested, questioning the relationship escalator, and building deeply loving, committed relationships without sharing a home.

And being unnested doesn't mean living alone! I live with my two teenagers. Other people live with friends, roommates, parents, or chosen family. We're just not organizing our households around romantic partnerships.

We're getting into autonomy, intimacy, commitment without cohabitation, and why romantic love doesn't have to be the center of your domestic life.

Because you don't have to share a home to share a life. 💜

In this episode, we're exploring:

  • Why polyamory doesn't have to revolve around a nesting partnership

  • The relationship escalator and the expectations we carry into non-monogamy

  • What it means to intentionally choose an unnested life

  • Why living with family, friends, or roommates doesn't make you any less unnested

  • How autonomy, interdependence, and intimacy can coexist

  • Building commitment without cohabitation

  • Why romantic love doesn't have to be the organizing center of your life

  • Giving yourself permission to want something different, and to change your mind

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

📰 Subscribe to Not A Monogamous Newsletter to stay up to date with new episodes and offerings from Ellecia. https://elleciapaine.podia.com/newsletter

❤️ Enjoying the show?
The best way to thank us is by following and leaving a review or a note. And if you want more, join our Patreon! http://www.patreon.com/notmonogamous

👀 Find Us Online
🌍 Website:  https://www.elleciapaine.com
📘 Facebook:  https://www.facebook.com/elleciapaine
📸 Instagram:  https://www.instagram.com/elleciapaine/

Music: Composer/Author (CA): Oscar Lindstein
STIM IPI: 572 393 237

TRANSCRIPT:

Hey friends, welcome back to Nope, we're not monogamous. I'm Ellecia Paine, your non-monogamy relationship coach. And today I want to talk to you about something that I've been thinking about a lot lately. What does it look like to be polyamorous and not have a nesting partner? Like we spend a lot of time talking about polyamorous couples, right? Like how to open your marriage, how to navigate dating other people when you have a nesting partner, how to manage jealousy when your spouse falls in love. Those are all really, really important, right? Uh, they're really important conversations, obviously. I've had approximately uh 12 million of them on this podcast. But what about when you're not part of a nesting couple? What if that's something that you're that you're not trying to change? And not just because you happen to be single or because a relationship ended, or because you're waiting to meet someone that you want to live with. Like I'm talking about actually choosing to be like unnested, choosing to have romantic relationships, to fall in love, to build intimacy and connection and commitment with people without necessarily wanting to share a home with any of them. Cause I think that there's an assumption, even in the polyamorous community, that eventually you're going to want to nest with someone, to live with someone. Like sure, you can date multiple people and have all of these different relationships, but somewhere in there, you're going to find your person, right? The one you live with, the one you build your domestic life around. And maybe you will. Maybe that's exactly what you want. But what if it isn't? What if you love having uh romantic partners and you also really love having a home that isn't centered around a romantic relationship? And before we get like way too deep into this, I want to clarify something because when I say I'm unnested, I don't mean I live alone. Okay. Like I live with my two teenagers. I uh believe me, I am not living like this peaceful, solitary existence where nobody eats the food I was saving or leaves dishes in the sink. There's a lot of dishes in the sink. Like I still share my home. I still have other people's schedules and needs and messes to consider. There's still negotiations about who's doing what and whose stuff is all over the living room. Um, and there's lots of ways to be unnested. Like you might live with roommates, friends, your parents, your siblings, your kids, or some combination of people that you've chosen to build a household with, right? Being unnested doesn't mean being isolated, and it doesn't mean you don't have a family or a community or people who depend on you. And it it does, it means you don't share your partner with a romantic partner. Nope, it means you don't share your home with a romantic partner. And I think that that's an important um distinction because we tend to organize so much of our understanding of relationships around romantic partnership. We assume that if you're building a home and a life with someone, that someone must be a romantic partner. But why? Right? Like, why do we assume romantic relationships are supposed to be the center of our domestic lives? Like, what if the people you share a home with and the people you're romantically involved with aren't the same people? And what if you actually really like it that way? So that's what I want to explore today a little bit. Stick with me on this. You know how we're taught that relationships are are supposed to progress, right? Like you meet somebody, you start dating, you fall in love, and eventually someone starts leaving a toothbrush at the other person's house, then there's a drawer, and then before you know it, you're discussing like whose couch you're keeping and which dishes you're keeping. And somehow we've decided that each of those steps means the relationship is getting more serious, more committed, like more legitimate, actually. And that's what a lot of people call the relationship escalator, right? This idea that relationships are supposed to move through a particular sequence of milestones and that each milestone represents some kind of progress. And even in polyamory, where we're supposed to be or should be, or you know, presumably are questioning traditional relationship expectations, we can still carry those assumptions around with us. Like we might have completely let go of the idea that romantic love has to be exclusive, but we haven't necessarily let go of the idea that one romantic relationship should be organizing the center of our lives, right? Um, I find it really interesting, actually. I do this too. Like we can, we can challenge monogamy and still hold on to so many of the structures that came with it. Uh, and I don't think that's necessarily intentional. I think a lot of us just, it's just what we've been taught. It's what we're used to. And for most of our lives, we've seen romantic, uh romantic partnership presented as like this ultimate goal, the big final step, right? You find someone, you build a life together, and eventually you share a home. And that's how you get fulfillment. And when people don't follow this path, there's this assumption that something must be missing. They must be sad, they must be doing something wrong. I mean, think about how people respond when a couple's been together for years and they don't live together, right? Like there's always someone asking, like, so when are you two finally going to move in together? Or is everything all right? Right? As though the relationship is just sitting there waiting to become a real relationship. And I think we do this in polyamory too, sometimes without even realizing it. Like we talk about nesting partners and primary partners and anchor partners, and those are all uh various valid ways of to describe relationships. But sometimes we start treating those roles as though they're the natural center of a polyamorous person's life. And everybody else exists around that center. Which I understand because a lot of times if you're uh a monogamous couple opening up or or or have a nesting partnership, a lot of times that feels like it creates a sense of safety, a sense of structure that your brain can go, this is this is easy, this is good. Like we we did the thing, I don't have to worry about it, right? But like what if there isn't a romantic relationship at the center of your life? Like, what if you have several meaningful relationships and none of them involves sharing your home with them, right? Like, what if you're not trying to move those relationships towards cohabitation? Does that mean they're somehow less serious? Like, I don't think so. Uh, I think it just means that you're building your life differently than expected, which is one of the things that I love about non-monogamy. You're already doing that. So it gives us this opportunity to examine these assumptions and decide which ones actually work for us, right? Because, like, the relationship escalator isn't inherently bad. There's not, it's not bad or wrong. Like, if you want to move in with someone, get married, combine your finances, and build a household together, awesome. Do that. Solid goal, solid choice. But I want it to be a choice, not something you just do because it's expected of you, not something that you do because you've been taught that that's what love is supposed to become, that that's the goal, and that's what's going to fulfill you. So something that I've noticed as I've been settling into this chapter of my life is um there's something really lovely about having a home that isn't organized around a romantic partnership, right? And again, I have teenagers. So it's not like I'm just floating around doing whatever I want with no responsibilities and no impact to other people. Okay. I still have a household to run. There's people to feed and schedules to coordinate and bills to pay and all of the normal things that come with raising kids. But there's a different kind of freedom, autonomy, and not having my domestic life intertwined with a romantic partner. And I think that's something that I'm discovering I really appreciate, right? Like I've spent most of my adult life living with romantic partners. Um, I know what it's like to build a shared household, to have those everyday routines, to make decisions together about how you live. And there's a lot of beautiful things about that, right? Uh, there's something really sweet about, I don't know, uh, the ordinary intimacy of living with someone, making breakfast together, cooking dinner, falling asleep next to each other, cuddling on the couch, uh, watching movies, right? Like having someone there for all the little moments that make up a life. Um, and I don't want to dismiss any of that. Also, I get that with my partners. But I'm also discovering that I can have really beautiful, intimate, connected relationships without sharing a whole household, without the sharing the whole thing. Um, and it it does feel different. Like I can spend time with someone because we want to spend time together, not because we happen to live in the same place and happen to be home after work together, right? Like we can plan dates and sleepovers and weekends together. We can have adventures and create tradition traditions and build something meaningful. We can share chores with each other, we can support each other through things, and then we can go back to our own homes. And I know that might sound strange to people who really love nesting with a partner, but I think there's something kind of wonderful about it. I'm not looking at my relationships and wondering when they're going to become something else, new, better, finished, I don't know, uh matured. Like I'm not assuming that the next step in loving someone is figuring out how to combine our households. I get to enjoy the relationships for what they are and explore what we want to create together. And I think that's a really important thing to do because sometimes we get so focused on where a relationship is going and we forget to appreciate where it is. Right? Like we're looking for the next milestone, the next level of commitment, the next thing that's gonna prove that this relationship is meaningful, is secure, is steady and sure. What if it's already meaningful? What if it doesn't need to become more domestic to be more intimate? Right? Like what if it's already secure as it is? And I I also want to talk about autonomy um for a minute because I think it's an important part of the conversation. Autonomy is one of those words that gets thrown a around a lot in polyamorous spaces and relationship spaces, um, sometimes in really beautiful ways, sometimes in ways that make me want to like really bang my head against the wall. Because autonomy doesn't mean you get to go do whatever you want without considering anybody else, right? Like that's not what we're talking about. Like, we're talking about having the ability to make really intentional choices about your own life while still being connected to other people, while still having community, while still having relationships, friendships, family. And I think that this is where the conversation about being unnested, not living together, gets really interesting because we have this idea that the more committed we become to someone, the more our lives should merge. Like we start making decisions as a unit. We build routines around each other and we organize our lives around the partnership. And again, there's nothing inherently wrong with that, right? Like, but I don't think intimacy requires us to become one unit. And I don't think loving someone means we have to merge every part of our lives. Honestly, sometimes I think we really confuse enmeshment with closeness. Like we assume that because two people do everything together or share most aspects of their lives, that they must have this incredibly deep connection. But those things are not necessarily the same. I often see the exact opposite. Like you can share a home with someone and barely know what's going on in their inner world. You can have a partner who lives across town or across the country who knows, who knows you so deeply, who understands you, who supports you, who makes you feel seen and loved. So intimacy is not just about proximity, right? Like it's not just how many hours you spend in the same room. It's the quality of the connection you're creating. I I once had someone say to me that they would rather have 20% of the time with their partner that had 80% of like quality connection rather than 80% of their time with their partner that had 20% of the quality of connection. Right. And I think being unnested can give an opportunity to be really intentional about that, to have more quality time together, to have more fulfilling relationships. Because when you don't share a home, you have to make choices about how you're going to connect. You have to communicate about like when you're going to see each other, what kind of time you want together, how you're going to support each other. And not have as much time bogged down in the day-to-day routine, right? Like you can't just assume that because you're both going to be home tonight, you'll get some quality time together. And that can be challenging, right? But it can also be really freaking lovely because you can actively choose how you're going to show up for each other. I also want to add, I don't, I'm not talking about being hyper-independent either. Like I think sometimes, especially when people like are coming out of a relationship where they feel like they've lost themselves or or squashed a part of themselves, there's this temptation to swing really far in the other direction, um, to decide that independence means never needing anybody, never asking for help or support or cuddles, right? And that's not what that's not what I want. That's not what I want for anyone. I want interdependence. I want to be able to lean on the people that I love and have them lean on me. I want relationships where we support each other, where we uh care about each other's needs, where we can make room for each other in our lives. I just don't necessarily need all of that to happen under the same roof, right? Let's pause for just a moment. If something in this episode has landed with you and you're feeling that little nudge inside, I'd encourage you to get curious about it. Everything I share here is necessarily pretty general, right? But our work together is deeply, deeply personal. I don't know your relationships, your history, your patterns, or what your body might be trying to tell you. And so that's why, rather than just listening to the podcast, I also offer free clarity chats. In a clarity chat, I'm not going to tell you what to do. Instead, I'm going to ask you some thoughtful questions and gently guide you to notice what's happening in your body so that you can hear yourself more clearly. Because the truth is we're often too close to our own lives to see the patterns that we're playing out. And we can't always hear what our bodies are trying to tell us because we're busy managing, coping, or just like simply trying to get through the day, right? And sometimes all it takes is having someone ask the right questions, reflect back what I'm noticing, and and create a space where you can hear yourself more clearly. If through our conversation it becomes clear that coaching together is the right next step, then I'll share how we combine this deep inner work with practical tools to create lasting change in your life and in your relationships. So if you're ready to move beyond just listening and start listening to yourself, you'll find the link to book your free clarity chat in the description or go to alysiapain.com/slash chat. Enjoy the rest of the episode. Bye. And something else I've been thinking about when we talk about building a life with someone, we almost always mean a romantic partner, right? Like that's just kind of the default assumption. You grow up, you find your person, and then you build your life around that partnership and what they want. Um, your friendships become something that you fit around your relationship, your family relationships shift, your social life often starts revolving around couple activities. And again, I'm I'm not saying there's anything wrong with prioritizing a romantic relationship. Um, but I do think it's worth examining why the why have we decided that romance should automatically sit at the top of the relationship hierarchy? Because my life is full of relationships that matter to me a lot. I have my kids, I have really deep friendships, I have family, I have romantic partners, I have a big community. And all of those relationships are a part of what makes my life feel meaningful. And some of them involve romance, some involve sex, some don't, several don't, some involve shared responsibilities and daily life, some involve like adventures and emotional intimacy and long conversations. And I don't necessarily need to organize all of those relationships around like one romantic partnership. I can have a home that like centers my family life with my kids while also having romantic relationships that are deeply important to me. And someone else might have a home that they share with their best friend or with their siblings or with their parents, or maybe they live in an intentional community or have a multi-generational home, right? Maybe they have a roommate that they've lived with for 15 years who's one of the most important people in their lives. Like, why do we automatically assume that a romantic partnership should replace all of those other relationships as the center of someone's domestic world? I think there's something really powerful about recognizing that we can build our lives around all kinds of love. And that romantic love doesn't have to be the organizing principle for everything else. Right. And of course, that doesn't mean our romantic partners are unimportant or that we don't yearn. And it doesn't mean that they get whatever time and energy we have left over. It means we're being intentional about how all of our relationships fit into our lives. And that is a conversation I think we need to have more often with each other and like with ourselves, right? I don't think it gets questioned enough. So, like, what does commitment look like without cohabitation, right? Like, I think one of the most important or the most interesting things about choosing to be unnested is that it invites us to redefine what commitment means. Because we've been given all these external markers that kind of tell us how serious a relationship is, right? Moving in together, getting married, buying a house, combining finances, getting a pet, having kids, right? And when you take those things off the table or like stop assuming that they're the goal, then you have to figure out what commitment actually means to you. What does it feel like? What does it look like? And I really love that because commitment isn't a house. It isn't a marriage certificate, it's not a shared bank account. Those things represent commitments. They are a part of commitment, absolutely, but they aren't the commitment itself. Commitment is, I think, in how we show up. It's in the conversations that we have when things get uncomfortable. It's the way we care for each other when there's hard parts in life. It's in the willingness to keep learning more about each other, to make repairs when we hurt each other, to celebrate each other's growth. It's in making choices that reflect the relationship that we say we want to have with each other. And none of those things requires that we live together, right? You can be deeply committed to someone you see a couple of times a week. You can have a partner you've loved for decades and never shared a home with. You can have someone who's in uh who's an incredibly important part of your life without needing to combine every part of your life with theirs. You can be married to someone and not live with them, right? Like there's so many ways to live life. And I think this is where we get to be creative. Because instead of relying on traditional milestones to tell us what our relationships are supposed to look like, we get to have actual conversations and be really intentional about it. Like, what does commitment mean to me? What does it mean to you? What does it look like for us? What kind of support do we want to offer each other? How do we want to spend our time together? Like, what does it look like to be there for each other through like the different seasons of life? How do we make sure we're both feeling loved and considered? And those conversations are really important, whether you live together or not, right? Like, like I think when we're intentionally unnested, they become especially important because you can't just rely on the structure of living together to define the relationship for you. You can't rely on default time together. Uh, you have to create that definition together. You know, and this doesn't mean that I never want to share space with someone, right? Uh sometimes I think people hear, I don't want a nesting partner, and interpret that as I don't want anyone too close to me, or I don't want to share my life with someone. And that's not necessarily true at all. Um, I can want someone to spend the night. I can want someone to spend the weekend. I can want to wake up to next to them. I can want to cook dinner together, take trips together, spend holidays together, and have all kinds of shared experiences. I might even want to spend several days in a row together, right? Like I just don't necessarily want that to mean that we're moving towards permanently combining households. I don't want that to mean we're gonna argue over bills, right? And I I think we need more language for that because right now we tend to have like a very binary understanding of relationships. Either we're building a life together, which usually means moving towards living together, or we're keeping things casual. But there's like so much space in between those two things. So much space. Like you can be deeply committed, have a really committed long-term relationship that doesn't involve living together. You can have a partner who is family to you without sharing a home. You can make plans for the future without those plans, including sharing a mortgage or a bank account. Or you can, right? You can have really meaningful domestic uh moments together without needing to make domestic partnership the foundation of your relationship. And I personally think that's worth exploring. Um, because when we stop assuming that there's only one way for a relationship to grow, we open up all the possibilities for what they can become. We we open up all the potential. And also you get to change your mind. Okay. So I also want to say that like choosing to be unnested doesn't mean you're making this lifelong declaration that you're never gonna live with a romantic partner again. Maybe you feel really strongly that you want your own home for the rest of your life. Maybe you don't care. Maybe you're exploring what being unnested feels like and discovering that you really enjoy it. Maybe you're discovering that you don't like it, right? Maybe you're in a season of life where having your own household makes the most sense. Maybe someday that changes. That's totally okay. I think sometimes we get so attached to our like relationship identities and the structures that we start treating them like big permanent commitments. Like this is who I am forever. And like once, like once you've decided you're solo polyamorous or you prefer non-hierarchical relationships, or you don't want a nesting relationship, uh nesting partner, you're supposed to stick with that forever. But why? We're allowed to evolve. Okay. We're allowed to learn new things about ourselves or uh have different needs and desires at different points in our lives. I've had so many different kinds of relationships throughout my life, and they've all taught me something about like what I value and what I want. And I don't think that we need to look at those changes as failures or contradictions, or like you just you don't know what you want, or you don't know who you are. Like sometimes something that worked really beautifully for us in one chapter of our life doesn't fit the same way in another. That doesn't mean you were wrong before. It means we've changed. And I think that that's one of the most important things that we can give ourselves permission to do. Change. You get to change, you get to grow, you get to evolve, you get to decide you want something different, you get to change your mind. Like this is kind of what life is all about, isn't it? I so I want you to think about something for a minute. Like, if nobody expected you to eventually live with a romantic partner, would you still want to? Hypothetically. And I'm not asking that because I think the answer should be no. Your answer is probably absolutely yes. Um, maybe you love sharing a home with a partner. Maybe the everyday companionship is one of your favorite parts of being in a relationship. That's amazing. I love that. But maybe if you really stop and think about it, you realize that you've never actually questioned whether you want to live your life with a romantic partner or live in the same home with a romantic partner. It was just what you assumed would happen, right? Like that was just the next step. Or maybe you discovered that you really love having your own space, or living with friends, or building a home around your kids, or just having separate bedrooms, right? Or having a household that isn't centered on romance. And maybe you still want deep, committed, loving relationships. You just want those relationships to exist alongside the rest of the life that you're building rather than becoming the thing you organize your life around, right? I think there's something really kind of freeing about recognizing that we actually get to make those choices. Um, because the goal isn't build a relationship that looks successful from the outside. That's not a fulfilling life, usually. It the goal is more to create relationships that actually feel good to the people in the relationships. And sometimes that means living together, sometimes it doesn't. Neither one is inherently more loving or more committed. They're just different ways of building a life. So, so okay, here's what I want you to take away from the conversation. Being polyamorous without a nesting partner doesn't mean that you're missing something. Okay. It doesn't mean your relationships are less serious or less meaningful. And it doesn't mean you're waiting for someone to come along and complete your life. Maybe it does, but it doesn't have to. You can have a beautiful, deeply connected, loving life that includes romantic partners without having a romantic partner at the center of your household at the center of your life. Like you can build a home with your kids, your friends, your family, your chosen community, or live on your own. Um, you can still have love and intimacy and commitment and partnership. You don't necessarily have to share a home to share your life. And you don't have to follow the relationship escalator to have a relationship that's continuing to grow. And I think that that is one of my favorite things about intentionally creating our relationships. We get to decide what works for us, right? Like, not what society says we should want, not what our families expect of us, not what other polyamorous people are doing or think is the right way to do things. What actually feels good to you? What feels good and meaningful and sustainable for the people involved? And I think that is absolutely worth celebrating. Okay. And I do want to come back to this topic because there's another side of this to being unnested that deserves its own conversation. So that'll be another episode. Like, what happens when you're intentionally unnested, but the people you're dating have nesting partners? How do you navigate those different relationship structures? How do you build connection and commitment when your domestic lives look uh look different? Because there's some really, really interesting things to unpack there. And I want to give that conversation um the space that it deserves. But for today, I want to leave you with this. Your relationships don't have to look like anybody else's relationships to be real. And your love doesn't need a shared home to be important or to matter. And you get to build a life that actually fits you. So, like, take out of this what resonates, leave the rest. If this, if it feels good for you, take it, use it. If it doesn't, great. And if this episode episode got you thinking about like what your ideal relationship uh structure might look like, I want to hear about it. Are you intentionally unnested? Do you love having a nesting partner? Have your desires around living together, around cohabitation changed over time? Like tell us. I I I think we need more conversations about all the different ways that we can create meaningful relationships. And if you know someone who's questioning all of this, send them this episode. Right? Share it. Maybe it'll give them permission to imagine something else or uh clarity to be able to get more creative, right? Thanks for being here. Bye.

Next
Next

Your Partner Wants Someone Else. Does That Mean You're Not Enough?